Physical Address
Crimson Lynx Media Ltd
Scottish Provident House
76-80 College Road
London
HA1 1BQ
Physical Address
Crimson Lynx Media Ltd
Scottish Provident House
76-80 College Road
London
HA1 1BQ

Expensive repairs, restrictive parts policies and inconsistent grading continue to hold back the secondary market.
Speaking at the Mobile News Circular Summit in London, John Coleman, Director of Galaxy Value Innovation & Services at Samsung Electronics UK, said manufacturers must look beyond the initial sale and consider how devices can deliver value to second and third owners.

Coleman was joined by Fiona Dear, Co-Director of The Restart Project, and George Kamiya, Director of Climate Insights at the GSMA.
During the discussion Coleman outlined how its strategy of longer software support, certified refurbishment and simplified trade-ins is designed to keep Galaxy smartphones in circulation for multiple lifecycles.
The discussion highlighted both the commercial opportunities for manufacturers, operators and refurbishers and the continuing tensions over repair costs, spare parts and the pace of smartphone replacement.

Coleman pointed to Samsung’s commitment to seven years of operating system and security updates as a central element of its approach to extending smartphone lifespans.
Longer software support allows devices to remain useful and secure beyond their first ownership cycle, increasing their potential resale value.
Samsung’s Certified Renewed programme is another component of the strategy. Returned smartphones are refurbished by Samsung technicians, with replacement components including batteries where required, and sold with a two-year warranty.
Coleman argued that customer confidence is fundamental to the success of these programmes.
Consumers need to trust both the quality of the refurbished product and the company supplying it, while trade-in processes must be straightforward and offer a clear financial incentive.
He said operators and retailers have an important role in encouraging customers to return devices, providing the volume of stock needed to support a sustainable refurbishment market.
While Samsung emphasised the benefits of manufacturer-backed refurbishment, The Restart Project’s Fiona Dear argued that the industry must do more to make independent repair affordable and accessible.
She welcomed European right-to-repair legislation, which is helping drive improvements in repairability, spare-part availability and access to repair information.
However, she warned that high component prices, labour costs and restrictions on replacement parts continue to discourage consumers from repairing otherwise serviceable smartphones.
Parts pairing, where replacement components can trigger software warnings or restrictions, was identified as a particular concern.
Dear argued that compatible aftermarket components should be permitted, provided consumers receive clear information about the parts fitted and their quality.
Greater competition in replacement parts could reduce repair costs and make it economically viable to keep older smartphones in service.
She also called for tax incentives, including reduced VAT on secondary sales, to encourage refurbishment and resale and cited repair-café data showing that the proportion of phones successfully repaired had increased from below 50 per cent a decade ago to more than 60 per cent.
The GSMA’s George Kamiya highlighted a persistent gap between consumer interest in refurbished smartphones and actual purchasing behaviour.
Although rising new-device prices and greater environmental awareness are encouraging consumers to consider refurbished alternatives, concerns about battery health, device condition and inconsistent grading remain obstacles.
Kamiya said customers need reliable information about what they are buying, particularly whether replacement parts are genuine manufacturer components or aftermarket alternatives.
He argued that consistent industry-wide labelling and grading could improve confidence and make it easier for consumers to compare refurbished products across different sales channels.
Poor-quality refurbishment also presents a wider commercial risk, he warned, because negative customer experiences can undermine confidence in the entire secondary market rather than simply the individual supplier.
Operators could play a significant role in overcoming these barriers through trusted retail channels, device bundles, repair services and trade-in programmes.
The panel also examined how the industry can secure sufficient quantities of high-quality used smartphones to satisfy growing secondary-market demand.
Coleman acknowledged that consumers are keeping devices for longer, potentially restricting the availability of relatively recent models for refurbishment.
He highlighted Samsung’s Galaxy Club programme as an example of a model that encourages customers to return devices after one or two years, making premium smartphones available for subsequent owners while they retain significant resale value.
Kamiya suggested that leasing and device-as-a-service programmes, particularly in enterprise markets, could provide another predictable source of used devices.
Such arrangements can help operators and refurbishment businesses recover devices earlier in their lifecycle, when their condition and residual value may be more attractive.
However, Dear cautioned that encouraging faster replacement simply to generate refurbished stock could undermine the environmental objectives of circularity.
She argued that the priority should remain keeping devices in productive use for as long as possible, rather than accelerating replacement cycles.
Coleman maintained that the objective was to create value across multiple ownership cycles, including finding economically viable routes back into the market for older devices requiring more extensive refurbishment.
Despite differing views on aftermarket parts and replacement cycles, the panellists agreed that the success of the circular smartphone market depends on cooperation between manufacturers, operators, retailers and independent repair businesses.
Coleman said all participants benefit when devices retain their value and customers have confidence in their next purchase.
Dear called for refurbished smartphones to be marketed alongside new devices rather than treated as a secondary option, making refurbished purchasing a normal part of the retail experience.
Kamiya said consistent quality standards and transparent information would benefit the entire market, regardless of whether devices were refurbished by manufacturers or independent specialists.
For the mobile distribution and retail channel, the discussion underlined the growing importance of services beyond the initial handset sale.
Trade-in, repair, refurbishment, warranty support and residual-value management are becoming increasingly important commercial opportunities as manufacturers extend device support and consumers hold on to smartphones for longer.
But the panel’s central message was that extending device lifecycles will depend on more than technical improvements.
Unless the industry can make repairs affordable, refurbishment standards transparent and trade-ins simple, much of the potential value in the secondary smartphone market will remain untapped.