Orange mail order dealer goes under

Last week the Kent companys website was still online but all its telephone lines were out of order.

An Orange spokesperson confirmed: Walk and Talk has gone into administration.

No-one at WNT was available for comment. The appointed liquidators are Ned Ailyan and David Hudson of Begbies Traynor which is also handling the administration of Celltalk.

Begbies Traynor stated:

WNT Communications was placed in to voluntary liquidation on March 11. The company has ceased trading and all employees have been laid off.

We have not had an opportunity to review in sufficient detail the cause for the companys failure. It is difficult to estimate the amount of debts owed at this time.

Interest has been expressed in the business but it is unlikely it will be resurrected.

Walk and Talks demise comes only weeks after Oranges leading mail order dealer Celltalk was placed into administration with debts of 3.2 million (see story P6). This latest casualty leaves Orange with only a few smaller direct mail order dealers left. There is concern over the future of these dealers.

Mail order dealers have a problem because they suffer a much higher rate of returns than (Cont P2) high street retailers said an industry source who declined to be named.

Orange charges an administration fee of more than seven per cent if handsets are returned.

But some mail order companies have had return rates as high as 15 per cent.

Its hard to see how they can survive in a shrinking market.

Begbies Traynor administrator Paul Stanley who is supervising Celltalks situation agreed that mobile resellers were running into severe difficulties because they increased their overheads as if the high-margin boom year of 1999 was never going to end.

Kondor celebrates exclusive Dixons Stores Group coup

Under the terms of the deal Kondor will manage all aspects of The Links mobile phone accessory supply and sales including the design and layout of store accessory displays and defining the accessory product range. Kondor staff will spend time at Dixons head offices and have remote access to its IT systems. All other accessory companies wishing to supply mobile accessories to The Link will now deal with Kondor.

Dixons says the decision to let Kondor manage its accessory business was taken to allow The Link to streamline its operations. It also wants to concentrate on offering an increased range of Max It Up mobile services which include mobile gaming sports alerts celebrity voicemail ringtones and graphics.

Kondor chief executive Malcolm Benson says the agreement (Cont P2) has given the company a timely boost as it looks to expand its operations.

Were delighted to be managing the accessories category for The Link and to be involved at strategic level with them. We have built up a good relationship with Dixons over the last six years. But the business had to be renewed on a yearly basis. This agreement effectively secures the business for us.

We are not just a one-customer company. We do substantial business with The Carphone Warehouse and Vodafone even though we are not their sole suppliers. I am now looking to secure another big contract. Dixons has been important to us. The deal gives us stability and it takes any nervousness away. But we cant get complacent. The work starts now because we will have to deliver Benson says.

Benson is bullish about Kondors prospects for this year.

We are a cost-conscious business. We wish to continue expanding the business in to Europe through partnerships and alliances. We pulled out from acquiring the German accessory company MORE because it wasnt right for us.

In the meantime Benson says Kondor has filled the vacancies in its management team following the departures of former managing director Keith Westcott to Phones International and ex-sales director John Farwell to rival accessories company Online.

Ex-Caudwell man Stephan Ziegler becomes the new sales director and Andrew Wood has been appointed finance director.

Motorola tries Moto brand

A series of high-profile adverts and posters will promote phrases such as TranceMoto GlitterMoto CupidMoto etc. Sponsorship in the music industry is aimed at increasing the desirability of Motorola phones .

Also Motorola is streamlining the range enhancing the existing line-up and introducing a new advertising campaign.

Motorolas UK consumer marketing manager Rick Williams said that research showed Motorola had a dull image in the minds (Cont P2) of young people.

When focus groups say your product is boring you know something has to be done quickly. Moto aims to make Motorola appear more fun and dynamic than it has been for many years. Moto isnt going to be a total rebranding of the handsets. The phones will still show the Motorola name and logo. But it is a way of selling phones to younger consumers and key markets that currently look elsewhere.

As part of a 5 million marketing budget Motorola will sponsor MTV from June. In London the Capital FM Superstar DJs programme on Friday nights will be sponsored by Moto (full story P18).

Another accessories firm bites the dust

The company supplied mobile phone accessories to retailers such as The Link and Argos reports Bard Covington.

Apex called in receivers Silver Altman after it became apparent that there were not enough orders to maintain profitability in the face of diminishing margins and a shrinking customer base.

Apex lost its biggest customer The Link after Dixons Group decided to outsource the management of its accessory sales to Kondor (see story below).

Silver Altman head of liquidations Tim Brown told Mobile News:

The reason for the companys demise was a lack of further orders. The mobile phone market has changed. The company found it impossible to change with it. Some customers had taken their business elsewhere. Margins were too tight. The bottom has fallen out of the accessories market. Clearly selling mobile phone accessories is not a good way to make money.

The directors tried to expand into other areas but couldnt raise enough funds to do so. They decided to get out before things got serious says Brown.

Link managing director Nick Wood refutes any suggestion that The Link was responsible for Apexs demise.

Apex went bust before we made any decisions. It is not true (Cont P2) that we forced it out of business says Wood. Brown says Apexs creditors were on course to get good dividends until the banks intervened.

We managed to sell off large amounts of stock. Creditors could have been repaid. But Royal Bank of Scotland Invoice Finance decided to protect its interests and appoint its own receivers. That means there is likely to be a much lower dividend to creditors.

The news raises further fears about the state of the accessories industry. Last year Paragon (ex-Fone Range) went into administration after selling the Fone Range brand name and dealer base to Elite (see below). Ora Telecom also went into administration last November and has since been sold to Acson UK (Mobile News March 4).

CellStar in legal row over three defectors

Caudwell spokesperson Iain Macauley said:

We are aware there is a pending matter between CellStar and three former CellStar employees but this does not involve Caudwell Group in any way.

However Caudwell Group is apparently preparing to defend its employees and possibly take action of its own.

CellStar managing director David Aitken said:

We have taken action against three employees who left the company in a manner that was unacceptable to CellStar. Weve learned that solicitors have been instructed to defend our action and we are unsure as to whether the Caudwell Group has offered the employees legal help. But it is the same solicitors that Caudwell Group uses.

Millions of disposable GSM mobiles headed for the UK

The deal calls for a minimum purchase of a million of Hop-Ons GSM phones per year valued at more than $25 million annually. The phones will be distributed in the UK and Spain as part of the three-year exclusive agreement. The phones are expected to sell for around $30 ( 20) each in the USA.

Hop-On spokesperson David Pasquale declined to name the London distributor for competitive reasons. He said that discussions with a network to connect the phones are underway.

The agreement also gives Hop-On monthly recurring revenue of a percentage of the airtime sold to consumers.

Hop-On chairman Peter Michaels said: (cont P2)

The UK and Spain are very attractive markets for us because of the demographics and recognition as two of the worlds most heavily-travelled tourist locations said Michaels.

We are confident that the high interest in our phones will translate into additional purchase orders.

The phones will be sold with and require an earpiece/microphone for operation. They do not have keypads but rely on voice-activation. They come configured with 60 minutes of pre-paid airtime. The phone is not allocated a dedicated number. Instead callers are given a dial-up number and input a PIN number to be connected with the phone.

In America Hop-On will be distributing its products through some of the largest retailers and convenience stores.

Hop-On says it is aggressively seeking joint-venture opportunities with domestic and international network operators including marketing distribution sales and/or value-added services.

Such deals will involve either technology licensing for manufacture or marketing and distribution of Hop-On phones through a partners existing sales channels.

Dealers again accuse Orange of direct poaching

It is alleged Orange uses its credit-checking process to reject dealer-initiated connections only to contact the customer directly and connect the phones later on.

Matlock Mobiles proprietor Alastair Newton claims Orange is still actively poaching customers.

Newton told Mobile News that he will be sending Orange an invoice for unpaid commissions of around 450 after Orange rejected his sale of nine handsets to a corporate customer on the grounds that the customer didnt have three months proof of address.

Only a short time later Newton contacted the customer to see if he could resurrect the deal only to discover that Orange had connected all nine handsets directly.

Im furious said Newton. We did all the work but Orange has connected the customer direct.

I do not care how many denials they make in the trade press regarding poaching of customers. They are as active now as ever.

Even single phones are being knocked back by credit (cont P2) referrals to give them the opportunity to convert it in to a direct sale. I hope they drown in their debts after I move all my Orange customers to other networks.

I will be invoicing Orange for the lost commissions and some data cables that we ordered in for the customer that have no use elsewhere said Newton.

Oranges connection referral processes are far too slow. Orange demanded customer proofs. We faxed them over several times only to be told that Orange hadnt received them. It worries me when it takes Orange two hours and four faxes to connect a phone.

No wonder people are reporting fewer sales. How many phones can you connect at that rate?

Orange says it is investigating Newtons claims. Orange head of sales Stuart Henry responded by saying:

We take any allegation of Orange poaching customers from retailers very seriously and will investigate any allegation individually. Should any wrongdoing be found we will take appropriate action.

Should any dealer feel that they have been treated unfairly by Orange I urge them to contact Orange directly via their business manager or alternatively they can email our commercial support team Henry added.

In another development Northampton dealer Scancom has hit back at Orange national sales manager Adam Clarke who accused him of a lack of commitment in a letter which ended Scancoms dealer agreement.

Now Orange has agreed that Clarkes letter could have been worded more tactfully. Scancom boss Gary Pope was furious when Clarke terminated his direct dealer arrangement giving him three months notice and telling him to use an Orange distributor instead.

Clarkes letter stated:

It is evident the level of commitment you have demonstrated to Orange has fallen markedly recently. In light of this I have to advise you that we are no longer able to justify the cost of maintaining your direct account with us.

Therefore in accordance with Clause 7 schedule 1 of your dealer agreement with us I hereby give you three months notice of termination.

A furious Pope said his sales had dropped due to the lack of attention from Orange dealer managers and little stock.

He replied to Clarke saying:

Never accuse me of lowering my commitment to Orange. I have given Orange 99.9 per cent of our mobile phone connections since 1994.

While appreciating that we are not your biggest connector I have always strived to give you quality business customers. But this obviously counts for nothing.

You infer I am giving my business to other networks. I have customers waiting for Nokia 6210s 8310s and Ericsson T39s all of which you cannot supply because they are on allocation etc.

Since you got rid of [dealer manager] Paul Beard we havent even heard from a dealer manager let alone received a stock allocation.

Pope told Mobile News:

I was angered by the fact that it sent out a standard letter with no thanks for the business that we have given it in the past. We are not a big connector but who is? I accept it wants us to deal through a distributor.

New connections have dropped. Upgrade business is 10- times more than new connections. We are still moving the same amount of kit. But most of it is upgrade business.

I dont understand why Orange didnt set us some definitive targets. I cant accept the impolite manner in which it has dealt with this. I deal with my customers politely. Why dont they?

Oranges Stuart Henry said:

The letter to Mr Pope could have been worded more tactfully. It was sent in reaction to our inability to make contact with Mr Pope directly. A business manager has subsequently contacted Scancom and arranged to meet with Mr Pope.

Dealers who have a direct relationship with Orange are aware of clear criteria that include a minimum sales threshold. These criteria take into account the cost to service supply and manage the account.

We continually review the performance of all our direct dealers to confirm they are best served through a direct relationship with Orange.

BTCellnet says it will stand behind independents

BTCellnet sales director Mark Stansfeld told Mobile News:

We remain absolutely committed to the independents. We continue to support them. Were working more closely than ever with them. (Cont P2)

After our stores have been refurbished they will have dedicated business areas.

I envisage committed partners from the independent channel being invited to sell in these dedicated business areas.

We should be working even more closely with our closest business partners he said.

As we move towards complex applications the independents importance can only grow.

The challenge will be for those who have built their business models around volume. They will have to adapt to high-value solution-based sales. Well help them change promises Stansfeld.

If you walk away from a channel its very hard to get them to come back when you need them. I havent got all the answers.

I still have a lot to do. Though the proportion of business delivered by our independent partners is growing I understand a lot of trust still needs to be built up.

Stansfeld promised independents they will get to sell everything in the 02 portfolio.

BlackBerry the corporate email solution was originally sold only by BTCellnet corporate sales.

But because the network wanted BlackBerry to attract as many high-value customers as possible it is now sold through the independent channel.

Independents have brought in some excellent orders. They are doing really well in comparison with the network corporate sales forces. Independents know their geographical area and the opportunities out there. SMEs are not necessarily looking for the cheapest solution. They are looking for someone to sort out problems Stansfeld said (full story P20).

Counterfeit accessories seized in raid

The raids by 15 policemen and eight Trading Standards personnel on November 7 resulted from months of planning and investigations involving Online Mobile Phone Accessories and both Hackney Road and Waltham Forest Trading Standards.

Four men were cautioned and will be questioned by Trading Standards officers over the coming weeks. If convicted they could face substantial fines and jail terms of up to 10 years.

The seized goods made in China included many brands represented by Online together with high-profile designer clothes brands and cartoon characters. The fascias will be used as evidence in the prosecution of the raided companys directors. (Cont P2)

Mick Grace an ex-police and trading standards officer now advising Online said the counterfeit fascias were sold mainly by market traders and were rarely found in legitimate high street shops.

Traders bought the fascias for 2 to 3 and were selling them for between 10 and 15.

The cases we seized carried just about every designer name you care to mention.

The thing is the quality is so poor that if you carry them around in your pocket for a week the design will have rubbed off. The men who were cautioned in this raid will be dealt with by local authority solicitors. I cant see them wriggling out of this one.