Rogue traders and inadequate seller controls are threat to consumer confidence

VAT fraud, rogue traders and inadequate seller controls are threatening consumer confidence and creating unfair competition in the refurbished smartphone market, industry leaders warned at Circular Summit 2026 in London yesterday. 

Foxway, Ingram Micro Lifecycle and Reebelo warn that unscrupulous sellers, inconsistent grading and marketplace pricing practices risk undermining legitimate refurbished device businesses.

Then panel discussed how VAT fraud, rogue traders and inadequate seller controls are threatening consumer confidence

Speaking during the Marketplace Power Plays: Winning Inventory, Trust and Scale panel, Rohit Sodha, President of Recommerce Mobile at Foxway, Dave Kempton, Director of ReCommerce EMEA at Ingram Micro Lifecycle, and Colin Williams, Managing Director of Reebelo, questioned whether marketplaces were doing enough to protect legitimate suppliers and customers.

The discussion highlighted concerns about sellers exploiting margin VAT arrangements, supplying devices that do not meet regional specifications and competing on price without meeting the quality standards expected of established refurbishers.

Rogue sellers undermine legitimate businesses

Kempton warned that established suppliers face competition from smaller operators that can disappear and re-emerge under different identities.

He argued that marketplaces needed stronger seller-vetting procedures to ensure businesses were competing on equal terms.

“Ingram doesn’t really have the choice of some smaller sellers going bust and starting up as something else,” he said.

“We have to be really narrow in terms of what we do, and rightly so. But I think maybe the playing field should be made a bit more level.”

Sodha raised particular concerns about abuse of margin VAT arrangements, which are an important consideration in the economics of second-hand device trading.

He warned that unscrupulous operators could enter marketplaces, trade for a short period and then disappear, leaving platforms and legitimate sellers to deal with the consequences.

He also highlighted concerns about devices being sold that did not meet European market specifications.

Sodha argued that such practices damaged consumer trust and imposed additional customer acquisition costs on marketplaces.

“When the customer comes, loses trust, is gone,” he said, warning that winning back a lost customer could cost a marketplace another €120.

He questioned whether marketplace investors, focused on gross merchandise value and profitability, were paying sufficient attention to VAT abuse and product compliance.

“I think marketplaces have a moral responsibility to protect the consumer,” he said.

Race to the bottom

The panellists warned that marketplaces which prioritised the lowest advertised price could inadvertently reward sellers operating to lower standards.

Sodha said price should not be the sole factor determining which refurbished device was presented to consumers.

“Price alone is definitely a race to the bottom,” he said.

He suggested marketplaces should give customers clearer choices between the cheapest available handset, a certified higher-grade device and products supplied by sellers with stronger quality records.

This would allow legitimate refurbishers to compete on reliability and service rather than being forced into continual price reductions.

Williams said Reebelo already operated a curated marketplace model, vetting sellers before allowing them onto the platform and monitoring their performance.

He explained that the marketplace’s featured-offer algorithm considered quality metrics alongside price.

“We know who is selling, and if anything starts to go wrong, we take them out,” he said.

“If we think someone is cheating, using low-quality parts, gaming that, we can end the relationship.”

However, Williams cautioned against giving consumers too many competing offers and grading options, arguing that excessive complexity could lead to abandoned purchases.

Grading standards 

 

Kempton said inconsistent grading requirements across marketplaces created further challenges for legitimate suppliers.

Ingram Micro Lifecycle sells through more than a dozen marketplaces internationally, each with its own grading expectations and operational requirements.

He said the differences could make some marketplaces commercially unattractive, even where they offered access to substantial numbers of customers.

The panel agreed that customer trust depended on devices matching the condition advertised online, but achieving consistency remained difficult when marketplaces used different descriptions and grading systems.

Sodha said automated grading technology could help improve accuracy and remove some of the subjectivity.

Foxway processes around two million mobile phones annually and uses automated grading equipment, including Apkudo technology.

According to Sodha, its AI-assisted grading processes achieve a discrepancy rate of less than one per cent.

He argued that reliable grading was particularly important at the point of trade-in, where consumers could lose confidence if an initial valuation was subsequently reduced.

Marketplaces must take greater responsibility

The discussion raised broader questions about whether marketplace operators were doing enough to police their platforms.

Kempton said stronger vetting of sellers was essential, particularly where established suppliers faced competition from operators that might not be subject to the same commercial and compliance requirements.

Sodha argued that marketplaces needed to look beyond transaction volumes and short-term profitability to protect the long-term reputation of the refurbished sector.

He also pointed to industry bodies working with European policymakers to improve standards and consumer confidence.

The panellists agreed that price competition was important, but it needed to be supported by effective quality controls, transparent grading and stronger oversight of sellers.

Securing inventory

Alongside the concerns about fraud and marketplace standards, the panel identified securing reliable inventory as a major challenge for 2027.

Sodha estimated that around 800 million unused mobile phones were sitting in drawers across Europe and argued that operators, retailers and marketplaces needed to do more to encourage consumers to trade in their devices.

Williams said building long-term trade-in relationships would help businesses secure inventory without having to compete constantly on the open market.

Kempton also identified opportunities to extend established smartphone refurbishment and resale processes into laptops, tablets and other consumer electronics.

But the panel’s central warning was that the industry’s growth could be undermined unless marketplaces tackled unfair competition and improved controls over the businesses using their platforms.

For established refurbishers investing in compliant operations, accurate grading and customer service, competing against sellers that cut corners on VAT or product quality risks turning an expanding market into a race to the bottom.